I recently heard a story on NPR about the testing of words with baboons. The scientists weren't testing the animals to see if they could understand the words, but to see if they could comprehend whether something was a real word or not. They placed a touch screen in a room which if the baboon selected correctly the baboon would get a treat. The baboons were allowed to go into the room freely, whenever they wanted.
To the scientists' surprise, after some practice, the baboons were able to discern the difference between English words and nonsense words. For instance there could have been the word PERSON and the non-word POUEIRSEIKN. The baboons were able to figure out the non-word used too many vowels and had awkward consonant placement. Most of the baboons were able to figure out over 4,000 English words and one special baboon was able to correctly select over 11,000.
The results of this experiment indicate once the rules of English letter placement are learned, real words can be separated from unreal words. This has nothing to do with actually understanding the meaning of the words, but everything to do with pattern recognition. The baboons weren't learning English, they were simply learning how some symbols do not get placed next to other symbols in certain series.
This also means young children are probably doing the same thing. Pattern recognition and solving is in a very different area of the brain from language learning. Understanding this may lead to different approaches in teaching English in schools.
Recently 60 Minutes had a story on a very specialized form of Aphasia in which people cannot recognize faces at all. A young boy cannot pick his own mother out of a line up of faces. He must rely on other clues to guide him to her such as her voice, mannerisms, hair, dress, and of course other people pointing to her and declaring the face belongs to his mother. Conversely the episode also highlighted some people who are called "super recognizers", who can recognize every face they've ever seen. A woman from NYC could readily pick out faces from people she may have only seen once, ten years ago. She could also easily pick out faces of famous people when they were just children because age doesn't seem to affect her ability.
These two stories seem to share a link. It makes me wonder if the young boy who could not discern faces, may not be able to readily pick out certain patterns. Humans have an innate ability to see faces where faces are not, such as the face on Mars, or in the Moon, or Jesus on a grilled cheese sandwich. Growing up we had a bathroom flooring material that was made up of "broken" shapes. I could pretty much find a human face in every one of the little shapes if I looked long enough. This is just pattern recognition. Could the young boy pick out faces in our bathroom flooring too, or would he by stymied?
We tend to think of our brains as immensely complex. We have historically tried to keep ourselves elevated far above our animal brethren with our special computational abilities. However, experiments like the one above only go to show how many of our special functions are actually common. We now have computer programs that can recognize faces. Is it simply a combination of all these separate talents that truly makes human beings exceptional?
Showing posts with label language. Show all posts
Showing posts with label language. Show all posts
Sunday, April 15, 2012
Saturday, January 21, 2012
on Interpreting
This last Friday I was at my monthly Deaf Advocacy Committee meeting and noticed something interesting. While one of the hearing people was speaking I found myself watching the sign language interpreter. I do this a lot since I will always pick up some new sign, and I find the choices each interpreter makes to be fascinating.
This particular interpreter is brand new and the poor girl had to work for over two hours straight, signing what ten hearing people were saying and then saying what the deaf people were saying. She did wonderfully and didn't seem to tire. Her word choices were very insightful, choosing to sign the single word "goal" for the entire phrase "heading toward something better". Sure she may have lost a tiny nuance by omitting the word "better" but the meaning remained mostly intact.
What was so different this time is that I actually found myself tuning out the speakers and focusing on the interpreter. I was actually much more precise and clear. English speakers tend to throw in a ton of emotional baggage, judgments, humor and completely useless information into our sentences. The interpreter cuts most of this out and concentrates on the core sentence meaning.
A while ago I met the director of the Cleveland Hearing and Speech Center, Sue Bungard at Spaces Gallery to pick out some artwork for the Center, which since its construction has been virtually art-less. Sue is deaf but can read lips and speak excellently. She faced me and said "hello" and then as I began to tell her how my morning had been going, she turned her back to look at some of the colorful paintings on the gallery wall. I found myself standing there with my mouth open. I wondered for a moment if I should tap her on the shoulder so she could turn toward me and "hear" what I was telling her. Then I realized nothing I was saying was actually important in any way. It was just noise, or to Sue it was just a bunch of lip flapping. My guess is, since much of what people say is filler, she takes in the person's intent and then shuts her active-listening-mind off, essentially turning her back on the person.
I do sometimes wish people would be more succinct in their speech. Time and again I have been plagued with a student asking a 26-part question that requires a telling of personal history in order to "put it into context". Yes, this is an exaggeration, but not by any huge degree.
One can be too succinct. My partner Robert hates to listen to my stories which admittedly can tend to have too much information, asides, commentary and references. However, I like to tell stories in chronological order with the built-up payoff at the end. Robert on the other hand tells the punchline of the story first and then proceeds to fill in all the details afterward. Once I've heard the denouement, there's very little reason to listen to the rest of the story because there's no build-up.
An example of one of my stories may start out with "it was very cold yesterday", meander through "just like the Columbus Day storm of 1964", and finish with "her car slid out of control and hit the embankment!"
Conversely an example of one of Robert's stories may start out with "Did you hear that she was in a terrible accident yesterday?", which leads to, "it was only 19 degrees outside" and finally end with "she had just finished paying off that car too."
I wonder how the interpreter would phrase these stories? I'll bet she'd be very succinct.
This particular interpreter is brand new and the poor girl had to work for over two hours straight, signing what ten hearing people were saying and then saying what the deaf people were saying. She did wonderfully and didn't seem to tire. Her word choices were very insightful, choosing to sign the single word "goal" for the entire phrase "heading toward something better". Sure she may have lost a tiny nuance by omitting the word "better" but the meaning remained mostly intact.
What was so different this time is that I actually found myself tuning out the speakers and focusing on the interpreter. I was actually much more precise and clear. English speakers tend to throw in a ton of emotional baggage, judgments, humor and completely useless information into our sentences. The interpreter cuts most of this out and concentrates on the core sentence meaning.
A while ago I met the director of the Cleveland Hearing and Speech Center, Sue Bungard at Spaces Gallery to pick out some artwork for the Center, which since its construction has been virtually art-less. Sue is deaf but can read lips and speak excellently. She faced me and said "hello" and then as I began to tell her how my morning had been going, she turned her back to look at some of the colorful paintings on the gallery wall. I found myself standing there with my mouth open. I wondered for a moment if I should tap her on the shoulder so she could turn toward me and "hear" what I was telling her. Then I realized nothing I was saying was actually important in any way. It was just noise, or to Sue it was just a bunch of lip flapping. My guess is, since much of what people say is filler, she takes in the person's intent and then shuts her active-listening-mind off, essentially turning her back on the person.
I do sometimes wish people would be more succinct in their speech. Time and again I have been plagued with a student asking a 26-part question that requires a telling of personal history in order to "put it into context". Yes, this is an exaggeration, but not by any huge degree.
One can be too succinct. My partner Robert hates to listen to my stories which admittedly can tend to have too much information, asides, commentary and references. However, I like to tell stories in chronological order with the built-up payoff at the end. Robert on the other hand tells the punchline of the story first and then proceeds to fill in all the details afterward. Once I've heard the denouement, there's very little reason to listen to the rest of the story because there's no build-up.
An example of one of my stories may start out with "it was very cold yesterday", meander through "just like the Columbus Day storm of 1964", and finish with "her car slid out of control and hit the embankment!"
Conversely an example of one of Robert's stories may start out with "Did you hear that she was in a terrible accident yesterday?", which leads to, "it was only 19 degrees outside" and finally end with "she had just finished paying off that car too."
I wonder how the interpreter would phrase these stories? I'll bet she'd be very succinct.
Monday, March 28, 2011
on Deaf Communication
Robert and I have been taking an intensive class on PSE (Pigeon Signed English) which is like American Sign Language but the sentences are in English word order. It is the way deaf people sign to each other typically. If I do say so myself, we've gotten pretty darned good.
The other day we were at the Coit Farmer's Market for breakfast. It is the oldest operating farmer's market in the city, out near (or in) Collinwood. At one point we both heard the unmistakable sound of a deaf woman's voice; the voice that comes from never having heard the hard consonants, full open vowels or subtle tongue placements of the English language. Although Robert was extremely nervous, he approached the woman and asked in sign if she was deaf. The woman enthusiastically answered in the positive and a short, pleasant conversation commenced. It was just like our teacher Jen Carrick told us, the deaf community is so isolated in a hearing world, they get excited when someone can actually communicate with them. Later, I had my chance to sign with the same woman as we both looked at some baby goats. It was wonderful and I felt two inches taller.
The opening night film for the Cleveland International Film Festival was named "Hamill" and was about a deaf wrestler who went on to become a champion. We had been able to secure a few extra tickets (thank you Marcy, Patrick and the rest of CIFF!!!) and offered them to some of our classmates and a married couple whom I had never met. The wife was an interpreter and the husband was a deaf actor. At the extravagant gala after the film screening, I wanted to meet the couple, but I did not know what they looked like! So, I spent a good portion of the evening walking around the crowded rooms looking for anyone who was signing. Since the film was about a deaf man, there were many, many deaf people in attendance, which made my job difficult. However, each person I tapped on the shoulder was genuinely excited to speak with me and even though they were not the people I was looking for, they were eager to ask me many questions and tell me many things. I tapped the shoulder of one woman and then apologized for the interruption (in sign of course). I went on to ask her if her name was Mary Ellen (the wife in the couple I was searching for). This woman smiled warmly and then as slowly as her fingers could possibly move, she signed "my name is Cindy" and then showed me the deaf-sign for her name which was a "C" hand hovering around her chin. I laughed and told her, "Thank you for going so slow with me". The most delightful thing happened then. She asked me if I was from Cleveland and if I had gone to a local school for the deaf. I was immediately embarrassed and explained I was actually a hearing individual. Instead of being insulted, she was pleased I was learning. Again, I think I grew two more inches. I eventually found Mary Ellen and her husband Michael and we also had a wonderful conversation. By the end of the night my head was pretty darned huge!
The Film Festival has this thing called Film Slam, where local high school students can come by bus (with a teacher) to see short subject films in the morning. I always help out with this event because it is chaotic and difficult and I like the punishment. Imagine literally hundreds of inner city high school students arriving, usually at the same time, into a fairly narrow concourse. You have to guide them quietly to the proper theater and then keep them shushed while the film is going.
It is actually a lot of fun! This morning there was a contingent of deaf students from Max Hayes High School. Again I was able to put my signing into use! I leaped to action and started signing with the teacher. Again I was able to carry on a great conversation. He told me that I was really good at signing and was so thankful I was there. He told me most people in the world refuse to communicate with deaf people. I didn't bother to give my opinion that most people simply don't know the language, but I got his point well enough. God my head swelled up.
Then the teacher went to the restroom and one of the students started talking to me. His hands flew so fast I could barely even see them. My brain recognized some of the signs, but I couldn't put them into a flowing sentence. I think he said something like, "Film you ____ got _____last_____day_____not_____do you____question____over_____yesterday______" and on and on. I told him to please go very slow and perhaps he did by some slight percentage. He smiled but I could tell I was frustrating him a bit. He used a handful of signs I've never seen before and punctuated them with a question mark. He finger-spelled, but the letters weren't the perfect finger-positions of a teacher, they were the "lazy" fingers of a teenager, still done at breakneck speed. I continued to show the signs for "slow", "puzzled", "what?", and "missed it", and he continued to try to talk to me. Finally I shrugged, apologized and said, "I am stupid, sorry". He smiled and walked away.
My head probably shrunk down to the size of a pea. This was the real trial by fire and I flunked. Reading the sign of a teacher, or even an adult at a party who can recognize I'm slow is quite a different thing to trying to talk to a teenager. Of course I can take a little solace in the fact that hearing teenagers can be very difficult to understand too. Very little solace.
The other day we were at the Coit Farmer's Market for breakfast. It is the oldest operating farmer's market in the city, out near (or in) Collinwood. At one point we both heard the unmistakable sound of a deaf woman's voice; the voice that comes from never having heard the hard consonants, full open vowels or subtle tongue placements of the English language. Although Robert was extremely nervous, he approached the woman and asked in sign if she was deaf. The woman enthusiastically answered in the positive and a short, pleasant conversation commenced. It was just like our teacher Jen Carrick told us, the deaf community is so isolated in a hearing world, they get excited when someone can actually communicate with them. Later, I had my chance to sign with the same woman as we both looked at some baby goats. It was wonderful and I felt two inches taller.
The opening night film for the Cleveland International Film Festival was named "Hamill" and was about a deaf wrestler who went on to become a champion. We had been able to secure a few extra tickets (thank you Marcy, Patrick and the rest of CIFF!!!) and offered them to some of our classmates and a married couple whom I had never met. The wife was an interpreter and the husband was a deaf actor. At the extravagant gala after the film screening, I wanted to meet the couple, but I did not know what they looked like! So, I spent a good portion of the evening walking around the crowded rooms looking for anyone who was signing. Since the film was about a deaf man, there were many, many deaf people in attendance, which made my job difficult. However, each person I tapped on the shoulder was genuinely excited to speak with me and even though they were not the people I was looking for, they were eager to ask me many questions and tell me many things. I tapped the shoulder of one woman and then apologized for the interruption (in sign of course). I went on to ask her if her name was Mary Ellen (the wife in the couple I was searching for). This woman smiled warmly and then as slowly as her fingers could possibly move, she signed "my name is Cindy" and then showed me the deaf-sign for her name which was a "C" hand hovering around her chin. I laughed and told her, "Thank you for going so slow with me". The most delightful thing happened then. She asked me if I was from Cleveland and if I had gone to a local school for the deaf. I was immediately embarrassed and explained I was actually a hearing individual. Instead of being insulted, she was pleased I was learning. Again, I think I grew two more inches. I eventually found Mary Ellen and her husband Michael and we also had a wonderful conversation. By the end of the night my head was pretty darned huge!
The Film Festival has this thing called Film Slam, where local high school students can come by bus (with a teacher) to see short subject films in the morning. I always help out with this event because it is chaotic and difficult and I like the punishment. Imagine literally hundreds of inner city high school students arriving, usually at the same time, into a fairly narrow concourse. You have to guide them quietly to the proper theater and then keep them shushed while the film is going.
It is actually a lot of fun! This morning there was a contingent of deaf students from Max Hayes High School. Again I was able to put my signing into use! I leaped to action and started signing with the teacher. Again I was able to carry on a great conversation. He told me that I was really good at signing and was so thankful I was there. He told me most people in the world refuse to communicate with deaf people. I didn't bother to give my opinion that most people simply don't know the language, but I got his point well enough. God my head swelled up.
Then the teacher went to the restroom and one of the students started talking to me. His hands flew so fast I could barely even see them. My brain recognized some of the signs, but I couldn't put them into a flowing sentence. I think he said something like, "Film you ____ got _____last_____day_____not_____do you____question____over_____yesterday______" and on and on. I told him to please go very slow and perhaps he did by some slight percentage. He smiled but I could tell I was frustrating him a bit. He used a handful of signs I've never seen before and punctuated them with a question mark. He finger-spelled, but the letters weren't the perfect finger-positions of a teacher, they were the "lazy" fingers of a teenager, still done at breakneck speed. I continued to show the signs for "slow", "puzzled", "what?", and "missed it", and he continued to try to talk to me. Finally I shrugged, apologized and said, "I am stupid, sorry". He smiled and walked away.
My head probably shrunk down to the size of a pea. This was the real trial by fire and I flunked. Reading the sign of a teacher, or even an adult at a party who can recognize I'm slow is quite a different thing to trying to talk to a teenager. Of course I can take a little solace in the fact that hearing teenagers can be very difficult to understand too. Very little solace.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)